Eyeliner or Eyeshadow: Which Should You Apply First?

When it comes to applying eye makeup, the order in which you apply eyeshadow and eyeliner can significantly impact the final look. While personal preference plays a role, most makeup artists recommend a specific sequence that maximizes precision and results. Let's explore why applying eyeshadow first is often the preferred method, and when eyeliner first might be the better choice.

Why Eyeshadow Should Come First

Blending Made Easy

Applying eyeshadow involves blending multiple shades to create a seamless, cohesive look. If eyeliner is applied first, blending eyeshadow can easily smudge or disrupt the delicate line, requiring touch-ups. Starting with eyeshadow gives you a clean canvas to work with, making it easier to blend and achieve a flawless finish.

Precision in Eyeliner Application

Applying eyeliner after eyeshadow allows you to define your lash line without interference from powder fallout. This ensures a sharper, more polished look, as the eyeshadow provides a smooth base for the eyeliner. The contrast and definition between the eyeshadow and eyeliner will be more apparent and polished.

Minimizing Fallout Issues

Especially dark or glittery eyeshadows can create fallout, which can settle on your newly applied eyeliner, making your eye makeup look messy. Starting with a base of eyeshadow helps to minimize this issue, ensuring a cleaner, more professional finish.

Creative Freedom

Applying eyeshadow first provides you with a base to adjust the intensity and placement of your eyeliner. This is particularly useful for dramatic or layered eye makeup styles. You can play with different techniques and create unique looks with a bit more flexibility.

When Eyeliner Can Come First

While eyeshadow first is the most common and recommended approach, there are instances where applying eyeliner first can be beneficial:

For a Smudged Look

If you want to achieve a smoky or smudged eyeliner effect, starting with eyeliner allows you to soften it with eyeshadow, creating a blended, sultry appearance. This technique is perfect for a chic, subtle smoky eye.

Graphic or Bold Liner Styles

For precise graphic eyeliner looks, such as winged liner, some may prefer to apply eyeliner first. This ensures that the shape of the liner remains intact during the eyeshadow blending process, maintaining the sharpness and definition.

Using Cream Eyeshadows

With creamy eyeshadows, which can make the lid slippery, applying eyeliner first ensures that the eyeliner stays in place. This is crucial to maintain the sharpness and definition of the liner, especially when working with a slick surface.

Tips for a Flawless Finish

To ensure a seamless and flawless application, here are some tips for both eyeshadow and eyeliner:

Use a Primer

A good eyeshadow primer prevents smudging and ensures that both eyeshadow and eyeliner last longer. Apply a primer before starting your eye makeup routine to create a smooth and professional base.

Clean Up

Use a cotton swab or concealer to sharpen eyeliner edges as needed. This step ensures that your eyeliner is crisp and defined, enhancing the overall look of your eye makeup.

Match Formulas

Pair your eyeshadow and eyeliner formulas for a smooth application. For instance, use powder eyeshadows with pencil or liquid liners for easy blending, and use gel liners with cream shadows for lasting wear and a smoother finish.

Final Takeaway:
For most looks, applying eyeshadow first is the go-to method for a clean, blended finish. However, for specific styles that require eyeliner first, such as a smudged look or precise graphic liner, experimenting with this approach can yield desirable results. Always find what works best for your personal style and preferences.