Tan Effectiveness: Spraying vs. Self-Tanning | Tips and Tricks

How Long Does It Take to Get a Tan with and without Sunscreen?

When diving into the realm of tanning, two popular methods emerge: spray tanning and self-tanning using mousses and sprays. Both methods offer a sunless tan, but they differ in longevity, coverage, and the risk of unwanted orange tones. Let's explore how these methods compare in terms of achieving a dark, even tan without the risk of looking pasty or orange.

Spray Tan Technique for Optimal Results

To achieve the best results with a spray tan, opt for a skilled technician using high-quality tanning products. Some tanning solutions are subpar, leading to an orange coloration if applied too dark for your skin tone. I, personally, have tried countless tanning solutions, and my advice is based on extensive experience. For the best results, apply your spray tan every two weeks, with each application spaced one week apart. This method ensures a darker, longer-lasting tan with fewer color inconsistencies. Additionally, I strongly advise against using the Norvell brand for tanning, as it fades very rapidly. For achieving a deep, even tan, go for products that offer a natural-looking dark tan with a nice even fade.

Self-Tanner Application for Optimal Results

If you prefer to use a self-tanner, the same two-week application schedule with one-week intervals between each tan works well. However, due to the weaker strength of self-tanner mousse and spray, layering becomes necessary to achieve a darker tan. Start with one coat, allowing it to dry completely, and then apply a second layer. Some people even apply a third layer, but I recommend beginning with two layers and seeing how your skin reacts. Popular self-tanning brands that offer dark tones include:

Bondi Sands Ultra Dark Tanning Foam St Tropez in Extra Dark - Loving Tan Platinum Mine.Tan Foam in Absolute Insanely Dark, Dark Ash, and Ultra Dark

Mine.Tan products are rapid tans, meaning you don’t need to leave them on as long, and the Absolute color is the darkest of the three. These products are designed to give you a deep, even tan without the need for excessive layers.

Optimal Sun Exposure for Tanning

While it's tempting to soak up as much sun as possible, it's crucial to understand that the key to tanning is to avoid burning. Your skin's ability to tan without burning varies based on the amount of melanin you have. Individuals with darker skin, abundant melanin, can stay in the sun for longer periods before turning pink, while those with lighter skin may require only a few minutes before needing to cover up with clothing.

The most important takeaway is to avoid burning under any circumstances. To increase your tanning success rate, consider improving your vitamin D levels to an optimal range, which can help you tan more effectively without burning. However, if you have light skin and are allergic to most trees, grasses, and molds, tanning may not be feasible for you. In my case, as someone in my 70s with little melanin and a severe tree, grass, and mold allergy, I have completely given up on tanning due to the hassle and discomfort of having to run to the tanning salon regularly. Tanning beds also have strict guidelines, with a mandatory 24-hour waiting period to minimize the risk of burning.

In conclusion, whether you choose spray tanning or self-tanning, the key to achieving a long-lasting, even tan is to follow a consistent application schedule and select the right products. Always prioritize protecting your skin from burning, even when tanning, to ensure healthy and beautiful results.